LDL is Not the Be All and End All

Milwaukee, Aug. 31, 2023 – While you may not be able to squeeze blood from a stone, François Poulletier de la Salle successfully isolated cholesterol for the first time from a gallstone in 1769 when his peers believed blood contained only a single protein and no fat. Scientists worked busily to define its molecular formula and shape, and better understand its connection to the accumulation of plaque in blood vessels and the development of heart disease. The first statin was approved by the Food and Drug Administration in 1987 to treat patients with high cholesterol and reduce their risk of suffering heart attacks and strokes. More recently in 2015, the FDA approved a new type of drug, known as proprotein convertase subtilisin-kexin type 9 inhibitors, to give cardiologists another tool for patients whose cholesterol levels are still too high after treatment with statins alone.

Unfortunately, even with these advances, heart disease is still the leading cause of death in the US according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Stroke continues to be a major issue as the fifth leading cause of death in the US. One clinical trial following patients taking proprotein convertase subtilisin-kexin type 9 inhibitors demonstrated a benefit while also revealing an opportunity for improvement as the absolute risk reduction was considered modest at 1.5 percent.

“It is clear that there is more going on than just what statins and these newer inhibitor drugs can control,” says Ze Zheng, MBBS, PhD, MCW assistant professor of medicine (endocrinology and molecular medicine), co-leader of the MCW Cardiovascular Center’s Atherosclerosis, Thrombosis and Vascular Biology Program, and associate investigator at Versiti Blood Research Institute. “More therapies are needed, and to get them we need to know more about other sources of risk for heart disease, especially heart attacks and strokes.”

There are several forms of cholesterol circulating in our bloodstream. The type commonly referred to as “bad cholesterol” is carried by a protein called apolipoprotein B (apoB) which forms well-structured particles with lipids and proteins. These particles serve as stable vehicles for transporting lipids such as cholesterol in the bloodstream. These lipid-rich particles mostly include very-low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) and low-density lipoprotein (LDL). The current drugs for lowering cholesterol reduce LDL levels. While substantial evidence shows that LDL is important to control, it is not the only risk factor for heart disease. In fact, the other lipoproteins in the same group as LDL are not reduced by much with available treatments. Dr. Zheng and team are investigating how to reduce levels of other members of this family of lipoproteins, especially VLDL.

“With my background in lipid metabolism, I found myself consistently checking lipid levels even during studies regarding blood clot lysis and how an impairment in the body’s ability to remove blood clots affects the risk of blood vessel blockages,” Dr. Zheng adds. “I was just naturally curious about it, and I noticed that a protein I was studying may have an effect on the amount of circulating cholesterol.”

In prior research, Dr. Zheng has helped define a new cellular source of this protein, tissue-type plasminogen activator (tPA), and its role in breaking down blood clots and preventing blood vessel blockages. To understand its potential influence on cholesterol levels, her team used a gene-editing technique to stop liver cells from producing tPA in mice prone to blood vessel plaque formation. The scientists found that the mice developed increased lipoprotein-cholesterol in this experiment, and then validated the findings in follow-up studies using human liver cells and a type of rat liver cell known to produce VLDL in a way similar to human liver cells. With these and other experimental results published in Science in September 2023, Dr. Zheng and her team have demonstrated a new, important role that liver tPA influences blood cholesterol levels while underscoring a meaningful connection between the liver, heart and blood vessels.

“After defining this new role for tPA, we turned our attention to the question of how it changes blood cholesterol levels,” notes Wen Dai, MD, research scientist, Versiti Blood Research Institute.

The liver contributes to the majority of the “bad” apoB-lipoproteins by making VLDL. The team focused on whether and how tPA impacts the process of VLDL assembly in the liver. Microsomal triglyceride transfer protein (MTP) is required for the assembly of VLDL due to its role carrying lipids to the apoB. The scientists determined that tPA binds with the apoB protein in the same place as MTP. The more tPA is present, the fewer opportunities MTP has to connect with apoB and catalyze the creation of new VLDL. If MTP is the quarterback trying to pass a cholesterol football to an open apoB receiver, then tPA is the cornerback breaking up the play.

“Based on our prior research, we knew it also was critical to look at tPA’s primary inhibitor,” Dr. Zheng says.

Plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1) is known to block the activity of tPA. Scientists also have found a correlation between PAI-1 levels in blood and the development of disease due to plaque formation and blockages in blood vessels. The team found that higher levels of PAI-1 reduced the ability of tPA to bind with apoB proteins, rendering tPA less effective at competing with MTP to prevent VLDL production. Returning to the biological gridiron, PAI-1 might be a decoy receiver that distracts tPA until MTP connects with apoB for a big gain. The team studied this interaction in human subjects with a naturally occurring mutation in the gene carrying the code for PAI-1. The researchers found that these individuals, as predicted, had higher tPA levels and lower LDL and VLDL levels than individuals from the same community who did not have the same mutation.

“We are investigating therapeutic strategies based on these findings regarding tPA, MTP and PAI-1,” Dr. Zheng notes. “I think we may be able to reduce the residual cardiovascular risk that has persisted even as treatment has advanced.”

Authors: Drs. Ze Zheng and Wen Dai worked with the following coauthors:

• Heng Zhang, PhD, postdoctoral fellow, Versiti Blood Research Institute
• Hayley Lund, BS, lab manager, MCW department of medicine (endocrinology and molecular medicine)
• Ziyu Zhang, MD, postdoctoral fellow, Versiti Blood Research Institute
• Mark Castleberry, PhD, research scientist, Versiti Blood Research Institute
• Maya Rodriguez, BS, student research assistant, Versiti Blood Research Institute, MCW DSHREP and StEP-UP Program
• George Kuriakose, MSc, Columbia University Irving Medical Center department of medicine
• Sweta Gupta, MD, Indiana Hemophilia and Thrombosis Center
• Magdalena Lewandowska, MD, Indiana Hemophilia and Thrombosis Center
• Hayley R. Powers, PhD, MCW Medical Scientist Training Program student
• Swati Valmiki, PhD, SUNY Downstate Medical Center department of cell biology
• Jieqing Zhu, PhD, senior investigator, Versiti Blood Center of Wisconsin Blood Research Institute
• Amy D. Shapiro, MD, chief executive officer, co-medical director and pediatric hematologist-oncologist, Indiana Hemophilia and Thrombosis Center
• M. Mahmood Hussain, PhD, professor, SUNY Downstate Medical Center department of cell biology
• José A. López, MD, chief science officer, professor, Bloodworks Northwest Research Institute and University of Washington
• Mary G. Sorci-Thomas, PhD, professor, associate director of Cardiovascular Center, MCW department of medicine (endocrinology and molecular medicine)
• Roy Silverstein, MD, chair and Linda and John Mellowes Professor of Medicine, MCW department of medicine
• Henry N. Ginsberg, MD, Herbert and Florence Irving Professor of Medicine, director emeritus, Irving Institute for Clinical & Translational Research of Columbia University
• Daisy Sahoo, PhD, professor, vice chair of medicine in research, MCW department of medicine (endocrinology and molecular medicine)
• Ira Tabas, MD, PhD, Richard J. Stock Professor and vice-chair of Research, Columbia University Irving Medical Center department of medicine

Funding: This work was supported by grants from the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, American Heart Association, American Society of Hematology, MCW and Versiti Blood Center of Wisconsin Blood Research Institute.

View the article in Science